Guild icon
Tulpa.info
Tulpa Discussion / tulpa-discussion
The channel for discussion strictly on the topic of tulpas. Take off-topic discussion to #lounge Forum's Tulpa Discussion Board: https://community.tulpa.info/forum/4-general-discussion/
Avatar
Where did you get it?
Avatar
I know it's in the settings, just haven't changed them yet on my windows install, i mainly use Arch
12:44 AM
it's fucking impossible to track down if you want to manually search for it, so here's the link
Avatar
...actually, at this point perhaps we should simply move to the lounge.
Avatar
Ripcord is a desktop chat client for group-centric services like Slack and Discord. It provides a traditional compact desktop interface designed for power users.
12:45 AM
yeah, actually
Avatar
@SkyeNet just for funsies we've been trying the parallel conversation thing and its been working decently well- host talking to his parents while I type I'm not convinced it's something a singlet can't probably manage but hey
Avatar
I'm wondering if you could use that in a higher form to listen to one thing via an earjack while the tulpa listens to something else, and then to be able to make a summary of what each of you heard
9:38 AM
Now that would be impressive
Avatar
It wouldn’t be too hard to carry out an informal research project on this...
Avatar
Oh man, can you imagine how hard it will be to listen with something in one ear and ignore something in another?
Avatar
Something something switching guide, but only half the body including half the head
10:00 AM
Logistics for such a thing would be horrible as far as I can predict
Avatar
The self integration of the audio system may make that impossible. Switching is not like possession. You can't half do it as far as I've ever seen.
Avatar
bduddy #Diana# 5/14/2018 2:30 PM
I remember finding an online parallel processing test like that (listening to two different things). Can't find it now though...
Avatar
In so far as I know the body has fixed limits regarding how much audio info it can process at once
Avatar
Compartmentalization and parallel processing are two very different things. As Maya said tulpa or not you only have one brain hardware wise. You could train your brain to handle multiple processes at the cost of something else but it's still one brain.
Avatar
@Mystes I am open to new ideas... With evidence behind them. Popularity of an idea along with anecdotes may mean it needs further study, but it does not mean that it is correct.
Avatar
What's normally followed doesn't always mean it's right. I don't think scientific stuff is always necessarily needed, but tulpas have a huge difference between imaginary friends.
Avatar
In addition, there is motivation for people to pretend when they receive encouragement as a result, especially if they are behaving in a manner highly consistent with a roleplay character.
7:31 PM
I assume you've publicly roleplayed before, @Mystes?
Avatar
I've done RPGs yeah
7:32 PM
but get this, what if it didn't matter. What if treating those RP characters like they were tulpas actually sped up their transition into actual tulpas
Avatar
Treating a roleplay character like a tulpa is not what I'm against.
7:34 PM
I object to treating a tulpa like a roleplay character.
7:34 PM
If someone takes the character and uses them as a focal point for making a tulpa rather than roleplaying as them, no issue.
Avatar
hm? how does that fit in the discussion? I may have missed something here
Avatar
I think... There is a disconnection in communication here.
Avatar
What I was thinking as well, I feel like there's two different things being discussed.
Avatar
When people treat their tulpas like roleplay characters (consistent parroting/puppeting - not just using it as an example), or "instantly get responses", there is a problem in each of these cases.
7:37 PM
In the first case, it is establishing roleplay as the pattern of behavior - not trying to establish independence and autonomy.
7:38 PM
In the second case, it is a lack of understanding of how the brain changes behavior - even assuming tulpas are "simply" altered automatic behavior rather than an independent and full mind, this takes time.
7:39 PM
A few days are far from long enough to establish that, and it discredits the phenomena to essentially anyone who does know about brain functioning when they see it claimed as true.
7:40 PM
I brought up the study about habits before - is anyone really saying that a tulpa is a simpler autonomous behavior than a single habit, or that a full independent mind is anywhere near that simple?
Avatar
hm, while I agree with the first point, and would add that the host would always be on the lookout to wean off the parroting/etc.
7:42 PM
I don't see a problem with the second. you don't need a full personality to hear responses. There's hypnagogia for one. If you make a ball of light and call it a tulpa, who's to say you can't hear a voice and call that a tulpa
Avatar
I rp frequently. It gives me an outlet to do virtual physical interactions with others. I can be in a shared space with other minds
Avatar
I'm convinced of my reality because I did not take as long as a habit to form.
7:42 PM
It happened overnight.
Avatar
yeah besides, anedoctes ^
Avatar
I am so lost here
Avatar
4th wall or not, emotes are great
Avatar
Anecdotes are not evidence.
7:43 PM
They are lovely if you want to believe something.
Avatar
they're quite substantial ways to observe that something is possible
Avatar
That said, when it comes to asking other people to believe it, anecdotes alone are unreliable.
Avatar
right now it's not even scientifically provable that tulpas exist afaik...so the scientific method is kind of out the window
Avatar
Ah... The problem is that people are unfortunately prone to error in memory.
Avatar
Hosts can own characters, why can't tulpae?
Avatar
I feel like there's confusion between "creating" a tulpa and a tulpa performing roleplay.
Avatar
@Solaria That isn't the issue.
Avatar
I think there's a very blurred line
Avatar
Oh, what is Winter?
Avatar
A tulpa choosing to roleplay is one thing. A host roleplaying in place of making a tulpa is the problem.
Avatar
I think constant roleplay can create a tulpa but the problem will be determining when the tulpa is actually speaking, and when you're just messing around (edited)
Avatar
Yes, that part is difficult
Avatar
Winter has been talking about what it is since before we swapped to tulpa-discussion. Winter articulates this much better than I ever could.
Avatar
I think roleplay is good as long as the TULPA is actually playing herself
7:45 PM
if you start playing the tulpa, you'll have problems
Avatar
You can't scientifically prove that anything exists technically. You can scientifically collect probabilistic evidence of tulpas.
Avatar
Humm.. In my case, I don't have a problem as the people I rp with besides select friends don't even know that I'm a tulpa
Avatar
That's fine.
Avatar
@9 Mil + Ika There are studies about related phenomena - DID is most direct. Other related studies involve speed of adjustment of the own brain, the propensity of the brain to rationalize beliefs and wishful thinking in absence of or even in the face of proof to the contrary, etc.
Avatar
I guess the reason we were even in server discussion was my comment to begin with 🤦
Avatar
This is why anecdotes are not permissible as evidence.
Avatar
@SkyeNet you lost me
Avatar
People are biased.
Avatar
As for rp diluting the community, it is a serious issue, but also a misses opportunity
7:46 PM
Missed*
Avatar
welp I'mma go eat
7:47 PM
be back later
Avatar
It's like everyone is missing Winter's point.
Avatar
no I get it
Avatar
Hard to make your own friends when in your host's shadow
Avatar
I just disagree
7:47 PM
anyway JA NE
Avatar
I mean, you can break any number of tulpa reports into a collection of anedoctes. If you doubt the base material you'd have to doubt any result stemming from them
Avatar
I'm not @Clo. RP could mean people role play as if a tulpa. Instead of letting a real tulpa rp
Avatar
There are servers people can go to if they want to roleplay. At this point, this server is more geared towards intellectual discussion rather than roleplaying - and given that seems to be quite rare, I personally would like it to stay that way.
Avatar
Good, good. I agree with you on the making friends aspect as well.
Avatar
@Mystes Anecdotes can certainly supplement studied data, and vice versa - but anecdotes alone are far from reliable.
Avatar
I agree with Winter. Perhaps instead we have a recommend rp server separate from the community, but where we can still mingle with friends here
Avatar
There's plenty. You just have to talk with the right people. (edited)
😉 1
Avatar
Even in the case of studies with more rigorous and defined data being used as a supplement, analyzing the relation and the quality of the data is important.
Avatar
I think I was more pointing in the direction that when you collect enough anedoctes they make a trend, and they get less and less dismissable regardless of nature
Avatar
I myself have rp communities
Avatar
Otherwise, people can and will claim quite a few things that don't hold up.
7:50 PM
Ah - more anecdotes of the same thing do indicate that it should be studied... But again, popularity is not evidence.
Avatar
well, weak evidence at the very least
Avatar
Humm.. I would like a non-4th wall deal, aka 'light rp' to emote as if in a shared space but not a 'in character' thing
Avatar
Large sample sizes are evidence.
Avatar
And, further, popular beliefs that fly in the face of more solid evidence are not uncommon.
Avatar
Eg. pokes Winter then flits away
Avatar
I don't care if people do light rp actions.
Avatar
Then I'm happy
Avatar
But, there is actually a rule against larger scale RP.
Avatar
Which makes sense. Hard to be serious when people rp everywhere
Avatar
Exactly.
Exported 100 message(s)
Timezone: UTC+0
Page 1 ... Page 53 ... Page 54 ... Page 55 ... Page 999